Introduction

A crispy Buffalo chicken sandwich can bring a delicious twist to your weeknight dinners or weekend gatherings. The combination of crunchy chicken, spicy sauce, and fresh toppings creates a mouthwatering experience that's hard to resist.

With a perfect balance of heat and flavor, this sandwich showcases the best of comfort food. Whether enjoyed at a backyard barbecue or a casual weeknight meal, it's a crowd-pleaser that's sure to satisfy.

Dive into the world of homemade Buffalo chicken sandwiches where you control the seasoning and crispiness. Let's bring this delightful dish into your kitchen.

Ingredients

4 boneless, skinless chicken thighs
Chicken thighs are preferred for their rich flavor and tenderness, ensuring a juicy bite when cooked. They provide a hearty base that stands up well to the bold flavors of the Buffalo sauce.
1 cup buttermilk
Buttermilk acts as a tenderizing marinade that infuses the chicken with flavor and moisture. The acidity in buttermilk breaks down protein, making the chicken incredibly juicy and flavorful.
1 cup all-purpose flour
Flour is essential for creating the crispy coating on the chicken. It helps achieve that golden-brown exterior when fried, providing a satisfying crunch that contrasts beautifully with the tender chicken.
1 teaspoon garlic powder
Garlic powder enhances the flavor of the chicken, adding a savory depth that complements the spices in the Buffalo sauce. It's a key flavor that rounds out the overall taste.
1 teaspoon paprika
Paprika not only adds a subtle sweetness but also contributes vibrant color to the batter, making the chicken look as good as it tastes. This spice is an integral part of many Southern-style recipes.
1/2 teaspoon cayenne pepper
Cayenne pepper elevates the heat factor of the dish and ties in beautifully with the spiciness of the Buffalo sauce. Adjust this quantity for your preferred spice level.
Salt and black pepper to taste
Seasoning with salt and pepper enhances the natural flavors of the chicken and the batter. Proper seasoning is crucial to prevent the dish from being bland.
2 tablespoons unsalted butter
Melted butter is an essential ingredient for blending into the Buffalo sauce, providing richness and depth. It also contributes to that authentic buttery flavor that you expect from Buffalo wings.
1/2 cup Buffalo sauce
Buffalo sauce is the star of this dish, delivering that signature tangy heat. Choose a sauce that matches your heat preference, as some brands can vary in spice level.
4 burger buns
Burger buns serve as the vessel for your crispy chicken and toppings. Opt for soft, sturdy buns that will hold up to the heat and moisture of the sandwich without falling apart.
Lettuce, tomato, and pickles for topping
Fresh toppings add crunch and freshness, balancing the heat of the chicken with crisp textures and refreshing flavors. They enhance the overall sandwich experience.

Directions & Preparation

Step 1: Marinate the chicken thighs in buttermilk for at least 2 hours, preferably overnight.

Marinating the chicken in buttermilk ensures that the meat stays juicy and full of flavor. If time allows, marinating overnight enhances the tenderness and infuses the chicken with the subtle tang of the buttermilk, making each bite even more delicious.

Step 2: In a bowl, mix flour, garlic powder, paprika, cayenne, salt, and pepper.

Creating the spice mix with flour is essential for the crispy coating. This blend not only gives the chicken its crunch but also infuses flavor into every bite. Make sure all dry ingredients are evenly distributed to ensure consistent seasoning.

Step 3: Remove the chicken from the buttermilk and allow excess to drip off, then dredge in the flour mixture, pressing it in to adhere.

Dredging the chicken in the flour spice mix is a crucial step for achieving that golden-brown crust. Pressing the mixture ensures that it clings onto the chicken, creating a thicker coating that fries up crispy and keeps the meat moist.

Step 4: Heat vegetable oil in a deep skillet or fryer to 350°F (175°C).

Ensuring the right oil temperature is vital for frying. If the oil isn’t hot enough, the chicken will absorb excess oil and become greasy. Conversely, if the oil is too hot, the exterior will burn before the chicken cooks through. Use a thermometer for accuracy.

Step 5: Fry the chicken in batches for 5-7 minutes until golden and cooked through.

Frying the chicken in batches prevents overcrowding, which can drop the oil temperature and result in uneven cooking. Cooking until the chicken reaches an internal temperature of 165°F ensures it's safe to eat and packed with juicy flavor.

Step 6: While the chicken is frying, combine melted butter and Buffalo sauce in a bowl.

Mixing melted butter with Buffalo sauce creates a rich, flavorful glaze that clings to the chicken. This step is crucial for achieving the correct texture and flavor profile typical of Buffalo chicken dishes.

Step 7: Once the chicken is cooked, transfer it to a paper towel-lined plate to drain excess oil.

Allowing the chicken to drain on paper towels helps remove excess oil, which is essential for achieving that crispy texture without being greasy. It also provides a moment to let the chicken cool before coating with sauce.

Step 8: Toss the fried chicken in the Buffalo sauce mixture until well coated.

Tossing the chicken in the Buffalo sauce while it's still warm allows the sauce to adhere better, creating a flavorful layer of heat without losing the chicken’s crispy texture. Be generous to get all the chicken nicely coated.

Step 9: Toast the burger buns lightly on the skillet or under the broiler until golden.

Toasting the buns not only enhances their flavor but also adds a nice crunch that contrasts with the tender chicken. This step also helps prevent sogginess from the sauce, ensuring a satisfying bite.

Step 10: Assemble the sandwich with crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato, and pickles on the toasted bun.

Layering the sandwich properly is key to a balanced bite. Start with crispy chicken as the base, followed by lettuce to add crunch, tomatoes for freshness, and pickles for acidity, making every bite enjoyable and flavorful.

Crispy Buffalo Chicken Sandwich step photo

Perfecting the Crispy Coating

The secret to an irresistible crispy coating lies in the dredging process. Ensure that the chicken is well-coated in the flour mixture by applying firm pressure. The combination of buttermilk and spices creates a flavorful base that not only adheres to the chicken but also provides a delightful crunch when fried. For an extra level of crispiness, consider a second dip in the buttermilk followed by the flour again.

Balancing the Heat

Buffalo sauce can vary significantly in heat levels. For those who prefer less spice, opt for a milder sauce or mix in some extra butter for a creamier texture. Additionally, garnishing with cooling toppings like creamy coleslaw or ranch dressing can help temper the heat and make the sandwich more enjoyable for those sensitive to spice.

Choosing the Right Buns

The bun can greatly influence your overall sandwich experience. A soft, sturdy bun, like a brioche or potato roll, can handle the sandwich's moisture and toppings without falling apart. A toasted bun adds textural contrast and warmth, enhancing the entire dish. Experiment with different types of buns to find your perfect match.

FAQs

What can I do if my chicken coating falls off during frying?

Ensure the chicken is well-dredged and press the flour mixture firmly onto the chicken. Also, avoid moving the chicken too much in the oil, allowing it to form a crust before flipping.

Can I use chicken breasts instead of thighs for this sandwich?

Yes, chicken breasts can be used, but be aware they may require more time to marinate to achieve optimal tenderness, as they can be drier than thighs.

What should I do if my Buffalo sauce seems too thin?

To thicken the sauce, add a little more melted butter and allow it to cool slightly before tossing with the chicken. This will help create a better coating.

What if my sandwich is too spicy?

To mitigate the heat, serve the sandwich with cooling toppings like ranch dressing or creamy coleslaw. This can help balance the spice and create a more enjoyable flavor.

How can I make this dish for a larger group?

Simply multiply the ingredient quantities by the number of servings needed. Consider frying the chicken in batches to keep things manageable and avoid overcrowding the oil.

What can I do if the chicken is overcooked?

If your chicken ends up overcooked, serving it with a generous amount of Buffalo sauce can help moisten it. Pairing with creamy toppings also adds moisture.

Conclusion

Crafting the perfect crispy Buffalo chicken sandwich at home allows you to tailor each component to your liking. With a touch of patience in marinating and frying, you’ll achieve a delicious outcome that rivals any restaurant.

Whether you're hosting a gathering or just treating yourself, this sandwich brings bold flavors and satisfaction to the table. Enjoy mixing and matching toppings to personalize your meal, and don't shy away from exploring different side dishes to complement your creation.

Recipe Card

Print Pin